Hi Cathy,
Sharon is right about what you need to do. Leaving Creepy Keep and entering Forever Forrest is a special place since the toll cost not only stars but also The Forrest Map, which can be found somewhere in The Volcano (like you needed Peegue's pass to get to the east of Wondertown). If you want to see where you need to go, try scrolling around the map (using shift+arrows). You will see Fire Island and The Volcano at the bottom of the map.
I hope this clarifies things a little
Oh...allmost forgot....
Welcome to The (Wonder)land of no sleep
Mette